Skip to content

optimism bias

PsychologyCognitionJudgment and decision-making

Summary

Optimism bias is the tendency to judge your own chances of good outcomes as higher, and of bad outcomes as lower, than the evidence or other people's outcomes support. The exam treats it as a systematic error in judgment about future events, not as a personality trait.

Detail

Meaning: Optimism bias is a cognitive bias in judgment in which people expect their own future to go better than the evidence, or the average person's outcomes, would support. A smoker may rate their own risk of lung disease below that of other smokers, or a student may expect to finish a project faster than similar past projects went. It is often explained by selective attention to favorable information and by motivation to protect self-esteem and reduce anxiety.

On the MCAT: A passage describes people estimating their own chance of a negative event, such as a car accident or divorce, compared with the average person. If the group's mean self-estimate falls below the true base rate, the group shows optimism bias. Questions may ask you to predict the behavioral effect: underestimating personal risk can lead to less use of seat belts, sunscreen or health screening. Others ask you to tell it apart from related biases.

Common confusion: Optimism bias is not the self-serving bias. The self-serving bias explains past outcomes (crediting success to oneself, blaming failure on the situation), while optimism bias predicts future outcomes. It is also an error in estimates, not a trait of cheerful people: the average risk cannot be below average for everyone, so widespread below-average self-ratings signal systematic error.

Sources

  • Psychology (Myers)
  • Psychology (Schacter, Gilbert, Wegner)
  • Social Psychology (Aronson, Wilson, Akert)

Written for the MCAT and checked before it was published. For study reference only. Spotted an error? Let us know.

optimism bias: MCAT Glossary